Spicy
Do you like a little sweet with a little heat? We Gotcha covered! These award-winning toffees are sure to please.
Bourbon Cayenne
New Flavor Alert! The Bourbon Cayenne Toffee is made with fresh pecans, delicious bourbon extr..
$8.85
Gotcha Toffee – Cashew Cayenne Pepper
Fans of everything spicy, will love this version of our Cashew Rich toffee made with a touch of caye..
$8.85
Gotcha Toffee – Cinnamon Pepper
Cinnamon fans will love this version of our Pecan Rich toffee made with a touch of cayenne and toppe..
$8.85
Hint of Hatch
New Flavor Alert! The Hint of Hatch Toffee is made with fresh pecans, just a 'Hint' of Hatch C..
$8.85
Toffee Sprinkles
Toffee Sprinkles are your new baking BFF! The perfect addition to your favorite cookie, cake, or pie..
$12.00
Gotcha Toffee – Habanero
This is our newest member of the Gotcha family. It is made with pecans, habanero spice, and milk cho..
$8.85
Gotcha Toffee – Ghost Pepper
If you like it spicy, you’ll love this blend of our pecan toffee and ghost pepper spice, finished of..
$8.85